There’s a bumper sticker that reads something like If you aren’t angry then you’re not paying attention
I’m having one of those days. Seems like as soon as I got up this morning and started paying attention to what was going on I was furious. Major props to Michael Isikoff who wrote this story in the current issue of Newsweek.
It goes like this:
On March 8th (2006) at the University of Freiburg in Switzerland Antonin Scalia was asked questions about the state of things at the Guantanamo prison and the rights of the folks there. Scalia completely dismissed the questions and said that the folks currently being held at Guantanamo don’t really have any rights. Let me say that again, Scalia said that the prisoners at Guantanamo don’t really have any rights. Seems that Scalia thinks that the prisoners don’t have rights to civil trials and they don’t have rights under the geneva conventions.
Scalia also seems to be confused about the folks who are being held prisoner at Guantanamo. Scalia made reference to his son fighting in the war against the folks who are being held. His son has served in Iraq, however, there are no Iraqis being held at Guantanamo.
I suppose that a supreme court justice stating that prisoners of war don’t have any rights and being confused about who exactly is being held at Guantanamo might not bother everyone. Now consider the fact that the supreme court is going to hear arguments in the case of at least one of the folks currently being held at Guantanamo, I don’t know about anyone else but this kind of thing makes me nervous.
So let’s review:
- Scalia thinks that the folks in Guantanamo don’t have rights
- Scalia is confused about who is being held at Guantanamo
- Scalia is about to decide on a case involving someone being held at Guantanamo
This kind of behavior gets right up my left nostril.
For further reading check out:
Check out Scalia in his on words (mp3). Is it me, or does this clown, yes I called Antonin Scalia a clown, does this clown sound pompus, arrogant and dismissive of anyone elses opinion?


